Maybe both? An exchange between my brother & I regarding my desire to apply to Strategos’ guild left me with a lot of food for thought:
ME: Hey Bro, Babyfresh wants to join StrategosGuild. To be honest, I do as well. I really like their organization, leadership, raiding with them, and they have concrete Wrath plans.
BRO: Honestly, I’m getting really sick and tired of your waffling back and forth. Go join them then. I’m going to start a war with that friggin guild tho. Their guildmaster is a shady piece of shit and he was actively poaching you two gullible fools. He even admitted to Quagmire that he was poaching you guys. What a scumbag. I’m calling him out ON his vent and in trade chat.
ME: Omg… We wanted to raid and he let us raid with him. It’d be different if our guild were raiding and he tried to get us to raid with him instead of our guild…. But since our guild isn’t raiding it’d be obnoxious to accuse him for doing us a favor!
BRO: Doing you a “favor” with the SPECIFIC MOTIVE of poaching 3 already guilded players. That’s not a favor. That’s a dirty trick. Especially since all their officers were in on the scam and they were laying guilt trips on you guys. This is NOT according to me, this is according to Quagmire and [Anonymous]. These guys are scum, making their own guildies sit out so randoms could play, just so they could guilt you into eventually joining. And you fell for it. You know, you may have raided a lot in the past 4 months or so, but in reality you’re such a noob when it comes to WoW, it’s not even funny.
He’s scum. And you’ll find that out eventually when you’re on the OTHER side of seeing him telling guildies to sit out so randoms can take their DKP.
I would never ask guildies to sit on the bench so I could poach randoms. Any good guild leader wouldn’t. It sets a terrible precedent. And I’m sure you think he’ll never do it again, right? If he was any good as a leader he’d have made you guys app instead of spitting in the face of all the guildies who HAD TO APP to get into his guild.
And I like how you put in that they have “concrete” plans on what to do in Wrath, like anyone’s plans for Wrath are ANY DIFFERENT from ours.
I have to lol at this. Stealing guildies, yes, that’s a HUGE favor!
Well! I take his words with a grain (more like block) of salt, but still I am a bit disturbed. LOL the part about me being a gullible noob at WoW really stunned me, and I look back at this post with new eyes and wonder if it was extraordinarily naive of me. Either I’m to be really naive, or really cynical huh!
